Productivity too low

How Lagarde and Nagel want to strengthen the internal market

Productivity in Europe is low. ECB President Christine Lagarde and Bundesbank President Joachim Nagel are urgently calling for reforms to be accelerated—and are putting forward proposals on what the EU should focus on.

How Lagarde and Nagel want to strengthen the internal market

In their speeches at the European Banking Congress (EBC) in Frankfurt, ECB President Christine Lagarde and Bundesbank President Joachim Nagel emphasized the great economic power that a completed European single market would have. „This is an enormous waste of potential – especially at a time when we need to rely more on ourselves than on others,“ Lagarde said of the current situation. „The key point here is that radical changes would not be necessary to achieve these benefits.“

Full harmonization of all regulations in the individual EU member states is neither politically feasible nor necessary. However, greater „mutual recognition“ would be a major step forward. According to Lagarde, a service or product that is permitted in one EU country should be freely tradable throughout the EU without having to comply with the granular regulations of each individual member state. Lagarde identified the different VAT regulations, which make cross-border trade difficult, as one of the obstacles to the single market.

To ensure greater harmonization in Europe, Lagarde supports the proposal for an optional EU-wide legal framework for companies – the so-called 28th regime, which Mario Draghi and Enrico Letta proposed in their respective reports to the EU.

Improving financing

Joachim Nagel also advocated the introduction of the 28th regime at the EBC. „This legal framework would simplify cross-border transactions, further reduce compliance costs, and enable companies to expand more quickly.“

However, according to Nagel, this alone is not enough. There is an urgent need for deeper and more integrated capital markets. Startups have insufficient access to venture capital financing. But also larger companies have difficulties obtaining liquidity due to fragmentation in Europe. This slows down economic growth.

High time pressure

Nagel and Lagarde urge the EU to speed up reforms. „If we truly create a unified internal market, Europe's growth will no longer depend on the decisions of others, but on our own decisions,“ Lagarde said. „That was my message six years ago. Today, that message has become even more urgent. Another six years of inaction – and lost growth – would not only be disappointing. It would be irresponsible.“ At the same time, Lagarde emphasized that completing the internal market would more than compensate for the burden on the euro economy caused by US tariffs.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) recently made a similar statement. EU productivity could increase by 20.2% if structural reforms were implemented, barriers to internal trade were removed, and labor mobility was raised to the level of the US. This would also enable Europe to close its productivity gap with the United States.

Statistical pitfalls

Nagel also sees an urgent need for action in Europe. However, he points out that the starting position may not be as bad as is often portrayed in public. After all, productivity is ultimately only a means to an end. The really decisive factor is the standard of living of the population.

This is not so easy to determine, because looking at gross domestic product alone is not enough. In his speech, Nagel also cites a number of statistical pitfalls. To compare living standards, differences in price levels would have to be taken into account. Statisticians usually work with purchasing power parities for this purpose. According to Nagel, the uniform basket of goods and services required for this is „not fully representative of all the countries considered.“ In addition, there are gaps in the data, which means that some prices have to be estimated.

„However, the following can be said with a high degree of certainty: taking into account differences in price levels and their changes, the standard of living in Europe has not developed as poorly as the unadjusted figures suggest when compared to the United States.“ But that is no reason for Europe to sit back and relax.